WitipediaIt's funny because it's true.
Create account Log in

Tacoma Narrows Bridge: Difference between revisions

(page creation)Newer revision (05:25, 28 September 2026)  52.38.225.52 (New page from the article seed)
Line 1:Line 1:
+
{{Infobox
+
| title = Tacoma Narrows Bridge (1940)
+
| opened = 1 July 1940
+
| collapsed = 7 November 1940
+
| wind at collapse = 42 mph in Farquharson's timing; the state history says about 40
+
| motion = torsion, about 0.2 hertz
+
| textbook explanation = resonance, from vortices shed by the wind
+
| frequency of those vortices at 42 mph = about 1 hertz
+
}}
+
The '''1940 Tacoma Narrows Bridge''' was a suspension bridge across the Tacoma Narrows, in Washington state. It opened on 1 July 1940. It collapsed on 7 November 1940, in a wind of 42 miles per hour, twisting itself apart while a camera ran. The film is still shown in physics classes, usually as an example of resonance. The engineers who worked on the collapse do not think that is what the film shows.<ref name="billah">K. Yusuf Billah and Robert H. Scanlan, "Resonance, Tacoma Narrows bridge failure, and undergraduate physics textbooks", ''American Journal of Physics'' 59 (1991), pp. 118-124.</ref><ref name="wsdot">Washington State Department of Transportation, "Tacoma Narrows Bridge history: Lessons from failure".</ref>
+
+
== What fell ==
+
The deck was stiffened with solid plate girders, eight feet deep, rather than an open truss. It was light, and it had very little resistance to twisting. For months it had moved in the wind in a vertical wave, which is why it was already called Galloping Gertie before anyone came to film the end of it. On 7 November the motion changed. A cable band on the north side slipped, the deck began to twist, and the twist grew until the span failed.<ref name="wsdot" />
+
+
The Federal Works Administration sent Othmar Ammann, Theodore von Kármán and Glenn Woodruff to find out why. Their report, in March 1941, blamed the bridge's flexibility, and the way a solid girder and deck in a wind produce lift and drag, like a wing that should not have been a wing. Aerodynamic forces on bridges, they said, were poorly understood, and future designs would have to be tested as models in a wind tunnel.<ref name="wsdot" />
+
+
== The textbook ==
+
Billah and Scanlan, writing in 1991 for an audience of physicists, counted the textbooks that used Tacoma Narrows as a classroom example of forced resonance: a structure shaken by a periodic push at its own natural frequency, the push being the vortices the wind sheds behind a girder. They then did the sum. At 42 miles per hour the natural rate of that vortex shedding is about 1 hertz. The twist that destroyed the bridge, timed by Professor F. B. Farquharson as he watched it, was 0.2 hertz. The two numbers are not the same number. Vortex shedding was not driving the collapse.<ref name="billah" />
+
+
What was driving it, in the engineering account, is aeroelastic flutter. The deck's own motion changed the wind force on it, and the changed force increased the motion. The damping, which is what bleeds energy out of an oscillation, became negative. The bridge supplied its own push. Forced resonance and self-excitation are different mechanisms, and the paper's point is that fifty years of undergraduate explanation had been using the wrong one, with the film as evidence.<ref name="billah" />
+
+
The film is genuine. The wind speed is genuine. The sentence that usually accompanies them in a physics course is the part that does not survive the arithmetic.
+
+
== References ==
+
{{reflist}}
+
+
[[Category:True but improbable]]
+

← Back to Tacoma Narrows Bridge  |  Full history