Donoghue v Stevenson: Difference between revisions
| (page creation) | Newer revision (05:25, 28 September 2026) 52.38.225.52 (New page from the article seed) |
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | {{Infobox | ||
| + | | title = Donoghue v Stevenson | ||
| + | | court = House of Lords | ||
| + | | citation = [1932] AC 562 | ||
| + | | decided = 26 May 1932 | ||
| + | | majority = Lord Atkin, Lord Thankerton, Lord Macmillan | ||
| + | | dissent = Lord Buckmaster, Lord Tomlin | ||
| + | | question actually decided = whether the written case, if true, disclosed a cause of action | ||
| + | | snail proved at trial = the case never went to trial | ||
| + | }} | ||
| + | '''Donoghue v Stevenson''' [1932] AC 562 is the House of Lords decision that a manufacturer can owe a duty of care to a person who did not buy the product. The person was May Donoghue. The product was a bottle of ginger beer, bought for her by a friend at a cafe in Paisley. The bottle was opaque. When the rest of it was poured out, her case said, the remains of a snail came with it.<ref name="atkin">''Donoghue v Stevenson'' [1932] AC 562, speech of Lord Atkin: the sole question was whether the pursuer's averments, if true, disclosed a cause of action.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | The House of Lords did not find that there had been a snail. It found that, if there had been, she was allowed to sue. | ||
| + | |||
| + | == The point of law == | ||
| + | Lord Atkin opened on the limit of the appeal. The only question was legal. Did the things Mrs Donoghue had written in her pleading, taken as true, amount to a case the court could hear? If yes, there would be a trial, and at the trial someone would have to prove the snail, and the fault. If no, there was no point calling witnesses.<ref name="atkin" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | By three votes to two, the answer was yes. A manufacturer who sends out a product that is meant to reach the consumer with no reasonable chance of an intermediate inspection, Atkin held, owes that consumer a duty to take reasonable care. He called the people owed that duty neighbours: persons so closely and directly affected that one ought to have them in mind.<ref name="atkin" /> Lords Buckmaster and Tomlin dissented. They thought a duty without a contract was a step the law had not taken and should not take. | ||
| + | |||
| + | == The snail == | ||
| + | The appeal was allowed and the case went back to be tried on the facts. It was not tried. The defender, David Stevenson, died. The action was settled, and dismissed by consent, without a hearing of evidence. The Scottish Council of Law Reporting, which keeps the session papers, has put the court record of that ending next to a long-running rumour that a judge later found there was no snail. The record does not say that. It says the case stopped. The Council's conclusion is the careful one: whether there was a snail in the bottle was never proved, and never disproved.<ref name="sclr">Scottish Council of Law Reporting, "Was there ever a snail in the bottle?", note on the court record in ''Donoghue v Stevenson''.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | The neighbour principle, which is the starting point of the modern law of negligence in the jurisdictions that inherited it, rests on a fact that was assumed for the purpose of argument and then settled before anyone had to prove it. | ||
| + | |||
| + | == See also == | ||
| + | * [[Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company]] | ||
| + | * [[Jaffa Cakes]] | ||
| + | |||
| + | == References == | ||
| + | {{reflist}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Category:True but improbable]] | ||
| + | |||