WitipediaIt's funny because it's true.
Create account Log in

Liebeck v. McDonald's: Difference between revisions

(page creation)Newer revision (05:26, 28 September 2026)  52.38.225.52 (New page from the article seed)
Line 1:Line 1:
+
{{Infobox
+
| title = Liebeck v. McDonald's
+
| court = a jury in Albuquerque
+
| plaintiff = Stella Liebeck, 81
+
| the cup = 49 cents
+
| holding temperature in the manual = 180 to 190 degrees Fahrenheit
+
| compensatory award = $200,000, reduced to $160,000
+
| her share of the fault = 20 per cent
+
| punitive award = $2.7 million
+
}}
+
'''Liebeck v. McDonald's''' is the 1994 Albuquerque case in which a jury awarded damages to Stella Liebeck after she was burned by coffee from a drive-through. The number that travelled was $2.7 million. The coffee, by the company's own manual, was supposed to be brewed at 195 to 205 degrees Fahrenheit and held at 180 to 190. A law student hired by the defence had already found that other cups in the city came no closer than about 20 degrees to the temperature at which McDonald's poured it, about 180 degrees Fahrenheit.<ref name="gerlin">Andrea Gerlin, "McDonald's counts the cost of hot, hot coffee", ''Wall Street Journal'', reprinted in ''The Independent'', 4 September 1994.</ref>
+
+
Liebeck had bought a 49-cent cup. While she was taking the lid off to add cream and sugar, it spilled. The burns on her groin, inner thighs and buttocks were third degree. The jury found the company liable, then set compensatory damages at $200,000 and cut that figure to $160,000 because it put 20 per cent of the fault on her for spilling it. Punitive damages were a separate question. Her lawyer had suggested one or two days of the company's coffee sales, which he put at $1.35 million a day. The jury chose two days, $2.7 million. When the story was printed, the company had asked for a new trial, and the judge had not yet ruled. He had the power to cut the figure.<ref name="gerlin" />
+
+
== What the headline kept ==
+
Cornell's Legal Information Institute records the later step. The trial court suggested reducing the punitive award to $480,000. The parties settled for a confidential sum before there was a final judgment.<ref name="wex">Legal Information Institute, "Liebeck v. McDonald's Restaurants (1994)", Wex, Cornell Law School.</ref>
+
+
The sum people repeated was two days of coffee. The cup had cost 49 cents.
+
+
== See also ==
+
* [[Leonard v. Pepsico]]
+
+
== References ==
+
{{reflist}}
+
+
[[Category:True but improbable]]
+

← Back to Liebeck v. McDonald's  |  Full history