Fallstreak hole: Difference between revisions
| (page creation) | Newer revision (17:36, 4 October 2026) 52.11.109.186 (Fallstreak hole: cavum, sourced to the Cloud Atlas and the aircraft papers) |
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | {{true and funny|source=World Meteorological Organization, International Cloud Atlas, cavum}} | ||
| + | {{Infobox | ||
| + | | title = Fallstreak hole | ||
| + | | image = Fallstreak hole suburb.jpg | ||
| + | | caption = A fallstreak hole in a deck of altocumulus over a suburb. The hole is an oval of blue sky. A brick apartment block sits at the lower right. A faint bright patch sits at the upper right edge of the hole. Photograph supplied for this article. | ||
| + | | wmo name = cavum | ||
| + | | also called = hole-punch cloud | ||
| + | | what it is = a hole in a thin layer of supercooled water-droplet cloud | ||
| + | | usual clouds = altocumulus and cirrocumulus; rarely stratocumulus | ||
| + | | what falls out = virga, or wisps of cirrus | ||
| + | | what does not fall out = the neighbors | ||
| + | }} | ||
| + | A '''fallstreak hole''' is a hole in a cloud of water that has been below freezing and has declined to freeze. The World Meteorological Organization, which does not do nicknames, calls it a '''cavum'''. The other name is hole-punch cloud.<ref name="wmo">World Meteorological Organization, ''International Cloud Atlas'', 2017 edition, supplementary feature cavum, section 2.2.2.4.9. https://cloudatlas.wmo.int/en/clouds-supplementary-features-cavum.html. The live atlas was not answering on 4 October 2026, so the wording here was checked against the Internet Archive capture of 28 January 2021: https://web.archive.org/web/20210128113338/https://cloudatlas.wmo.int/en/clouds-supplementary-features-cavum.html.</ref><ref name="met">Met Office, "Fallstreak hole." https://weather.metoffice.gov.uk/learn-about/weather/types-of-weather/clouds/unusual-cloud-formations/fallstreak-hole. The Office's other name for it is "holepunch cloud," one word.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | It looks like the sky opened and took people. It did not. It took supercooled water and left the ice, which is the only honest rapture.<ref name="wmo" /><ref name="nesdis">NOAA National Environmental Satellite, Data, and Information Service, "Fallstreak Clouds." https://www.nesdis.noaa.gov/fallstreak-clouds.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == What it is == | ||
| + | The International Cloud Atlas is where the WMO writes the definition down. Cavum, it says, is a well-defined, generally circular hole in a thin layer of supercooled water-droplet cloud. Sometimes the hole is linear instead. Virga, or wisps of cirrus, typically fall from the middle, and the hole generally grows larger with time.<ref name="wmo" /> From straight underneath, the Atlas says, it is a circle. From off to one side, which is how anyone in a suburb sees it, it goes oval.<ref name="wmo" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | It occurs in altocumulus and cirrocumulus, and rarely in stratocumulus.<ref name="wmo" /> The Atlas's table of which features keep company with which clouds marks cavum for those three genera and for no others.<ref name="wmotable">World Meteorological Organization, ''International Cloud Atlas'', 2017 edition, "Table of supplementary features and the genera with which they most frequently occur," section 2.2.2.4.12, table 9. Cavum is marked for cirrocumulus, altocumulus and stratocumulus. https://cloudatlas.wmo.int/en/clouds-supplementary-features-and-genera-most-frequently-occur-table.html. Read on 4 October 2026 from the Internet Archive capture of 4 January 2022, https://web.archive.org/web/20220104153424/https://cloudatlas.wmo.int/en/clouds-supplementary-features-and-genera-most-frequently-occur-table.html, for the same reason as the cavum page.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | The fallstreak is the ice on its way out. The Met Office's short version is that part of the cloud layer forms ice crystals large enough to fall, and that falling ice is the fallstreak.<ref name="met" /> The hole is what the cloud looks like after the water has changed its mind. | ||
| + | |||
| + | == Why the water leaves == | ||
| + | The cloud is liquid water below 0 °C. That is supercooling: cold enough to be ice, still a droplet.<ref name="met" /><ref name="nesdis" /> The droplets get away with it because they are short of anything to freeze onto. NESDIS lists the missing grit as dust, pollution particles, fungal spores or bacteria. NASA's account adds pollen, and says supercooling is routine rather than exotic. Altocumulus, on that same account, covers about 8 percent of Earth's surface at any given time and is mostly liquid droplets supercooled to about −15 °C.<ref name="nesdis" /><ref name="nasa">NASA Earth Observatory, "Making Sense of Holes in the Clouds," 26 February 2024. https://science.nasa.gov/earth/earth-observatory/making-sense-of-holes-in-the-clouds-152486/.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | The Met Office gives the droplets two exits. They find a nucleus, a tiny particle, and freeze on it. Or they are cooled below −40 °C, and then they freeze with nothing to hold onto.<ref name="met" /> A mid-level cloud is not usually starting from −40 °C. NASA, writing up the aircraft studies, says air expanding over a wing or past a propeller cools the droplets by another 20 °C or more, which can push them to freezing without the dust.<ref name="nasa" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | Once a few droplets have become ice, the rest of the neighborhood follows. The new crystals grow by taking water from the droplets around them, get heavy, and fall. The hole spreads as more of the surrounding droplets freeze.<ref name="nesdis" /> NASA's version of the same sequence is that ice crystals beget more ice crystals, then fall as virga: wispy precipitation that often never reaches the ground, left hanging in the middle of the hole.<ref name="nasa" /> The Atlas says the same picture in fewer words. Virga or wisps of cirrus fall from the center, and the hole gets bigger.<ref name="wmo" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | What left was the liquid. What you watch leaving is the ice. There is no second transaction. | ||
| + | |||
| + | == Airplanes == | ||
| + | An airplane is a reliable way to supply the missing cold. The Met Office's account is that air expands and cools as it passes over the wings or the propeller, and that the change can be enough to make the supercooled droplets freeze and fall in the pattern people photograph.<ref name="met" /> NESDIS describes the same expansion around the wings and the body, and calls it adiabatic cooling.<ref name="nesdis" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | Two papers led by Andrew Heymsfield are the ones that measured it. In 2010 the ''Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society'' published the first documentation of holes and channels cut in altocumulus by two commercial turboprop aircraft, and reported that airliners can make ice in cloud as much as 30 °C warmer than the −40 °C temperature where contrails form.<ref name="bams">Andrew J. Heymsfield, Patrick C. Kennedy, Steve Massie, Carl Schmitt, Zhien Wang, Samuel Haimov and Art Rangno, "Aircraft-Induced Hole Punch and Canal Clouds: Inadvertent Cloud Seeding," ''Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society'' 91, no. 6 (June 2010): 753–766. https://doi.org/10.1175/2009BAMS2905.1. The Denver measurements and the quotations below are from NCAR's account of this study, not from a paraphrase.</ref> In 2011 ''Science'' reported that hole-punch and canal clouds had been observed for more than fifty years, that the ice is droplets freezing in air cooled around propeller tips or over jet wings, and that model simulations have the growing ice driving vertical motions for an hour or more. That motion is what widens the hole and the canal. The global effect is minimal. Near major airports, the extra precipitation is not.<ref name="science">Andrew J. Heymsfield, Gregory Thompson, Hugh Morrison, Aaron Bansemer, Roy M. Rasmussen, Patrick Minnis, Zhien Wang and Damao Zhang, "Formation and Spread of Aircraft-Induced Holes in Clouds," ''Science'' 333, no. 6038 (1 July 2011): 77–81. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1202851.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | The case they caught with instruments was west of Denver in 2007. A research flight went through falling snow. The odd part showed up later, in a ground radar: a band of precipitation that had grown quickly and had a strange shape. Federal Aviation Administration tracks put turboprops from two airlines through the cloud on a standard flight path. Snow crystals started falling about five minutes after the second aircraft. The band ran about 20 miles long and 2.5 miles wide, lasted about 45 minutes, and left about two inches of snow on the ground.<ref name="ncar">National Center for Atmospheric Research, "Mysterious clouds produced when aircraft inadvertently cause rain or snow," NCAR & UCAR News, 14 June 2010. https://news.ucar.edu/2185/mysterious-clouds-produced-when-aircraft-inadvertently-cause-rain-or-snow.</ref> The crystals in that band were plate-shaped and rimed, meaning liquid water had frozen onto them on the way down. Ice elsewhere in the cloud had little or no riming. Heymsfield's conclusion, which is better than the theology, was: "This tells us that the aircraft literally 'seeded' the cloud just by flying through it."<ref name="ncar" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | The temperatures in that account are specific. The droplets that matter are already below about 5 °F (−15 °C). Over Denver they were still liquid at temperatures as low as about −35 °F (about −34 °C). A turboprop freezes them by the expansion at the propeller tips. A jet needs a colder cloud, below about −4 to −13 °F (−20 to −25 °C), and does the cooling with the wing.<ref name="ncar" /> Heymsfield's other line, the one the lab printed, is that flying an airplane through these clouds can produce as much precipitation as seeding them on purpose along the same path.<ref name="ncar" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | The shape depends on the angle. NASA, summarizing those studies, says a plane that passes through at a fairly sharp angle leaves a small circular cavum, and a plane that passes through at a shallow angle leaves a longer canal cloud with a trail of virga. Thickness, air temperature and horizontal wind shear change how long either one gets. Large passenger jets, regional jets, private jets, military jets and turboprops can all do it.<ref name="nasa" /> The Atlas, in the voice of a regulation, says that when the hole comes directly from an aircraft it is generally linear, a dissipation trail, and the virga falls from a trail that keeps widening.<ref name="wmo" /> Often that ice never reaches the ground, which is why it is called virga. West of Denver it did not. It snowed.<ref name="nasa" /><ref name="ncar" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == Why people think the world is ending == | ||
| + | From the ground the hole is a clean oval of blue with feathers of ice in the middle. NASA notes that people sometimes argue these are flying saucers or other unidentified anomalous phenomena, and that the formation can look as if a circle or an ellipse has been cut out of the cloud.<ref name="nasa" /> In October 2009 a hole over Moscow reached the front of Yahoo under the headline "A Halo over Moscow."<ref name="ncar" /> Scientists have been writing the things down since the 1940s. NCAR's history of the argument runs from acoustic shock waves, to local warming along a jet's path, to ice forming on contrails, before the measurements settled on inadvertent seeding.<ref name="nasa" /><ref name="ncar" /> That is a long time to spend explaining a cloud to people who have already decided it is a visitor. | ||
| + | |||
| + | The rapture reading is the same mistake with a better poster. A fallstreak hole is supercooled water finally doing what the temperature asked, and the ice falling out of the layer.<ref name="met" /><ref name="nesdis" /> The number of people taken is zero. That zero is not a census of a street. It is what you have left when the thing that left was water, and it was pulled out of my ass only in the sense that no study counted a congregation, because there was not one to count. | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[File:Fallstreak hole Dave illustration.jpg|thumb|center|480px|alt=A staged suburban yard under an oval hole in the clouds. A man in a blue plaid bathrobe holds a white mug. A golden retriever sits on an empty leash. A spatula and a burger hang in the air above a smoking grill. A red lawnmower is running. A pile of clothes and a pair of shoes lie on the grass. A yard sign reads TAKEN. DOG WAS NOT. A mailbox plaque reads IF YOU ARE THE RAPTURE, YOU FORGOT DAVE.|The man in the bathrobe is called Dave in this caption and nowhere else that matters. He is not a real person. He was not taken. The dog was not taken. The burger and the spatula left without anybody, which happened only inside the drawing. This is an illustration made for the article, not a photograph of an event, and not evidence of anything except that a hole in a cloud looks like a door. The hole is a cloud, not a door.]] | ||
| + | |||
| + | The photograph in the box above is a real one, supplied for this article: altocumulus, an oval of blue, a brick apartment block, a faint bright patch at the rim of the hole. The yard is the argument people reach for when they would rather have a doctrine than a phase change. The airplanes in the studies were not hovering over a judgment. They were climbing or descending on ordinary paths, and near a busy airport there are a lot of those paths. NASA's figure for Miami is more than 1,000 arrivals a day.<ref name="ncar" /><ref name="nasa" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | The sky opened, nobody got taken, and the plane that did it was already on approach. | ||
| + | |||
| + | == References == | ||
| + | {{reflist}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Category:True but improbable]] | ||
| + | |||