WitipediaIt's funny because it's true.
Create account Log in

Joseph Stalin: Difference between revisions

(page creation)Newer revision (02:01, 9 October 2026)  54.245.146.22 (New article. Sourced from theguardian.com, cambridge.org, smithsonianmag.com.)
Line 1:Line 1:
+
{{true and funny|source=Simon Sebag Montefiore, The Guardian, 18 May 2007: for the 70th birthday, translators including Pasternak were not told the author, one thought the poems deserved the Stalin Prize, and Stalin ordered the work stopped.}}
+
{{Infobox
+
| title = Joseph Stalin
+
| poems, 1895 = five, published in Iveria under the name Soselo, at age 17
+
| the name Stalin = coined in 1912, according to Montefiore
+
| 70th birthday, 1949 = a Russian edition of the five poems, commissioned and then stopped
+
| census = January 1937, then suppressed
+
| death = 5 March 1953, recorded at 9:50 p.m.
+
}}
+
'''Joseph Stalin''' is the name he coined in 1912. In 1895, aged 17, at the Tiflis seminary, the poet people had heard of was still Soselo.<ref name="mont">Simon Sebag Montefiore, "Before the terror," ''The Guardian'', 18 May 2007. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2007/may/19/featuresreviews.guardianreview32</ref>
+
+
== Soselo ==
+
Montefiore's essay says the 17-year-old showed poems to Prince Ilya Chavchavadze, who chose five to publish in ''Iveria'' under the nickname Soselo. Chavchavadze called him that "young man with the burning eyes." "Soselo was admired as a poet before anyone had ever heard of 'Stalin', the name he did not coin until 1912."<ref name="mont" />
+
+
The children's anthology ''Deda Ena'' included his first published poem, "Morning," in its 1916 edition, where it remained, sometimes ascribed to Stalin and sometimes not, up to the days of Brezhnev. The poems were usually published as "Anonymous." Other titles Montefiore discusses are "To the Moon" and "Old Ninika," the latter in the weekly ''Kvali''.<ref name="mont" />
+
+
He never publicly acknowledged the poems.
+
+
== The birthday commission ==
+
For the official 70th birthday in 1949, Lavrenti Beria secretly commissioned translators, including Pasternak and Andrei Tarkovsky, to make a Russian edition of the five. They were not told who the author was. One of them thought "this work is worthy of the Stalin Prize first rank." Then they received the stern order, clearly from Stalin himself, to stop work.<ref name="mont" />
+
+
The edition was commissioned. The translators did not have the author's name. The order that followed was to stop.
+
+
== The census ==
+
In January 1937 the government of the USSR conducted its first population census in eleven years. Catherine Merridale, writing in ''The Historical Journal'', says the questions included, for the first and last time, a question about the respondent's religion. "The information gathered was exceptionally thorough and complete. Crucially, however, the census was entirely suppressed, and the officials responsible for organizing it promptly arrested and executed."<ref name="merr">Catherine Merridale, "The 1937 census and the limits of Stalinist rule," ''The Historical Journal'' 39, no. 1 (March 1996), pp. 225-240, Cambridge Core, published online 11 February 2009. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/historical-journal/article/abs/1937-census-and-the-limits-of-stalinist-rule/EA2018DAD588327DE868929E99DE206F</ref>
+
+
Her abstract ties the suppression largely to the sensitivity of evidence of high mortality during the famine of 1932-3. In the notes printed with the article she records that Andreev, Darskii and Kharkova suggest roughly 8 million excess deaths in 1932-3. She also prints older, wider estimates: Maksudov, 9.8 million plus or minus 3 million, and Lorimer, 4 to 5 million. Those are citations on her page. They are not one agreed total.<ref name="merr" />
+
+
== 1 March to 5 March ==
+
Sheila Fitzpatrick, reviewing Joshua Rubenstein's ''The Last Days of Stalin'' in ''The Guardian'' on 18 August 2016, writes that after a stroke on the night of 1 March 1953, security could not prevent him lying for hours in his own urine, paralysed, and without the ability to scream. Servants and guards were worried about his non-appearance but afraid to disturb him. When his colleagues were finally called, they hovered uncertainly before finally calling a doctor. It was not his personal physician. That physician, and a number of his colleagues, had recently been arrested as traitors in the Doctors' Plot.<ref name="fitz">Sheila Fitzpatrick, review of Joshua Rubenstein, ''The Last Days of Stalin'', ''The Guardian'', 18 August 2016. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2016/aug/18/last-days-of-stalin-joshua-rubinstein-review</ref>
+
+
The treatment Rubenstein records, as Fitzpatrick lists it: absolute quiet; the application of eight medical leeches to his ears; a cold compress on his head; an enema of milk of magnesia; and the removal of his false teeth. He died without regaining consciousness on the evening of 5 March. Fitzpatrick writes that his closest colleagues did not kill him, despite speculation that Rubenstein rightly deflates. Within weeks of the death, the Kremlin physicians accused in the Doctors' Plot, mainly Jewish, were exonerated and freed.<ref name="fitz" />
+
+
''Smithsonian Magazine'', Jackie Mansky, 10 October 2017, describes a dinner on the night of 28 February 1953 at which he asked whether confessions had been extracted for a trial he would soon oversee. That winter, the magazine says, he had been waging a witch hunt against Kremlin physicians, many of whom were Jewish, claiming they had murdered top Soviet officials in a "doctors' plot." The trial against the Kremlin doctors was to commence within weeks. Beria, reached by phone, demanded they tell no one of the illness. Doctors were called around 7 in the morning. They found a blood pressure of 190/110. The clock time in the magazine is 9:50 p.m. on 5 March.<ref name="smith">Jackie Mansky, "The True Story of the Death of Stalin," ''Smithsonian Magazine'', 10 October 2017. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/true-story-death-stalin-180965119/</ref>
+
+
The "afraid to disturb him" line is Fitzpatrick's summary of Rubenstein, not a document she quotes in full. Smithsonian notes that Zhores and Roy Medvedev doubt the story that the staff were simply too frightened to open the door.<ref name="fitz" /><ref name="smith" />
+
+
His death was recorded at 9:50 p.m. on 5 March. He had not regained consciousness. The physicians who had been arrested were freed within weeks.
+
+
== References ==
+
{{reflist}}
+
+
[[Category:Politicians]]
+
[[Category:True but improbable]]
+

← Back to Joseph Stalin  |  Full history