Clever Hans: Difference between revisions
| (page creation) | Newer revision (05:25, 28 September 2026) 52.38.225.52 (New page from the article seed) |
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | {{Infobox | ||
| + | | title = Clever Hans | ||
| + | | species = horse | ||
| + | | owner = Wilhelm von Osten, Berlin | ||
| + | | apparent talents = arithmetic, reading, music, the calendar | ||
| + | | tested by = Oskar Pfungst, 1907, published 1911 | ||
| + | | actual talent = noticing when the questioner relaxed | ||
| + | }} | ||
| + | '''Clever Hans''' was a horse in Berlin, owned and tutored by a retired schoolteacher, Wilhelm von Osten, who believed the animal could calculate, read, tell the time and identify musical intervals. Hans answered by tapping a hoof. A commission of respected observers watched him in 1904 and could find no fraud. The psychologist Oskar Pfungst then tested the horse with the answer hidden from the person asking the question. The arithmetic stopped.<ref name="pfungst">Oskar Pfungst, ''Clever Hans (The Horse of Mr. von Osten)'', translated by Carl L. Rahn (Henry Holt, New York, 1911).</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | Hans could not do sums. He could tell when a person who could do sums thought the sum was finished. | ||
| + | |||
| + | == The test == | ||
| + | Pfungst called the two conditions "procedure with knowledge" and "procedure without knowledge". Von Osten whispered a number into the horse's ear. Pfungst whispered another. Hans was asked for the total. Each man knew only his own number, so the sum, if anyone in the yard knew it, was the horse. Then they repeated the problem with the answer known to the questioner. | ||
| + | |||
| + | In 31 trials without knowledge, Hans was right 3 times. In 31 trials with knowledge, he was right 29 times. Pfungst treated the three as chance. A counting test, with balls on a frame and the experimenter facing away, was passed every time the answer was known and failed every time it was not. A musical test went the same way. Across the series, knowledge produced correct answers 90 to 100 per cent of the time. Ignorance produced about 10 per cent, which is what chance produces.<ref name="pfungst" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | Pfungst's conclusion is a list of things Hans could not do. He could not read, count or calculate. He knew nothing of coins, cards, calendars or clocks. He could not tap back a number he had just been told. He had, Pfungst wrote, "not a trace of musical ability".<ref name="pfungst" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == The cue == | ||
| + | What Hans could do was watch. The questioner leaned forward while the hoof was tapping and straightened, slightly, when the right number had been reached. The movement was not performed on purpose. It was the posture of someone waiting, and then of someone who has the answer. Hans stopped when the posture changed. Pfungst measured it. If he leaned further forward at the tenth tap of a requested twenty, the horse sped up for the second ten. Of 34 such trials, 31 worked.<ref name="pfungst" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | Von Osten had not been signalling on purpose, which is why the 1904 commission found no trick. He believed the horse was thinking. The horse was watching him believe it. Asked a question to which nobody present knew the answer, Hans tapped anyway, and the number he arrived at was his own. | ||
| + | |||
| + | == See also == | ||
| + | * [[Ig Nobel Prize]] | ||
| + | |||
| + | == References == | ||
| + | {{reflist}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Category:Animals]] | ||
| + | [[Category:True but improbable]] | ||
| + | |||