WitipediaIt's funny because it's true.
Create account Log in

A Severe Strain on Credulity

From Witipedia, the funny encyclopedia
A Severe Strain on Credulity
PaperThe New York Times
Published13 January 1920, "Topics of the Times"
SubjectRobert H. Goddard's proposal that a rocket could work in a vacuum
Correction17 July 1969
Interval49 years
Last line of the correction"The Times regrets the error."

"A Severe Strain on Credulity" is an editorial note published by The New York Times on 13 January 1920, in the column "Topics of the Times". It concerns Robert H. Goddard, a physics professor at Clark College, who had proposed that a rocket could operate in the vacuum of space. The note said that he seemed to lack "the knowledge ladled out daily in high schools": the relation of action to reaction, and the supposed need for something better than a vacuum to react against.[1]

On 17 July 1969, with Apollo 11 on the way to the Moon, the Times published a correction. It quoted itself, cited Isaac Newton, and regretted the error.[2]

The 1920 note[edit]

Goddard had already shown, in a vacuum-chamber experiment funded in part by the Smithsonian, that a rocket does not need air to push against. The exhaust pushes the rocket. Newton's third law is the whole of the mechanism, and it does not require an atmosphere. The 1920 note treated that as a failure to understand school physics, and mentioned his academic post and the Smithsonian's support as if both were embarrassments.[3]

The sneer is specific. It is not that the engineering was hard. It is that the professor, with a chair and a grant, did not know what the editorial writer believed every high-school class already knew.

The correction[edit]

The 1969 item is short. It gives the date of the original, quotes the sentence about the chair and the high schools, and then says that further investigation and experiment have confirmed Newton, and that it is now definitely established that a rocket can function in a vacuum as well as in an atmosphere. "The Times regrets the error."[2]

Goddard did not live to read the correction. It ran on 17 July 1969, the day after Apollo 11 left Earth, in a paper that had kept the 1920 sentence in print long enough to have to quote it back to itself.[3][2] The high-school knowledge had been right. It had been Newton's, and it had been Goddard's. The vacuum was never the problem.

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ The New York Times, "Topics of the Times", 13 January 1920, p. 12. The passage is reproduced in the paper's own correction of 17 July 1969.
  2. ^ The New York Times, "A Correction", 17 July 1969.
  3. ^ Tony Reichhardt, "The Misunderstood Professor", Air & Space Magazine (Smithsonian), quoting the 1920 editorial and the 1969 correction.

Rate this article

Two questions, two separate answers. An article can be useless and hilarious, or accurate and dull; the ratings are kept apart so editors can tell which problem they have. Anonymous ratings are counted per IP address.

Was this helpful?Did you actually learn the thing? No ratings yet
Was this funny?Did the joke land, and was it true? No ratings yet