WitipediaIt's funny because it's true.
Create account Log in

Dead salmon fMRI study

From Witipedia, the funny encyclopedia
"Dead salmon" fMRI study
Formal titleNeural correlates of interspecies perspective taking in the post-mortem Atlantic Salmon
AuthorCraig M. Bennett et al.
Subjectone dead Atlantic salmon
Purposedemonstrating a statistical flaw in fMRI research
Presented asa poster at a 2009 neuroscience conference
Ig nobel prize2012, Neuroscience

The "dead salmon" fMRI study placed a whole, dead Atlantic salmon in a brain scanner, showed it photographs, and asked it to identify the emotional state of the people in them. The purpose was not a joke about fish, but a serious demonstration of a statistical error common in real neuroscience research.

The experiment[edit]

Neuroscientist Craig Bennett and colleagues at Dartmouth placed a dead salmon, purchased for the purpose, into a functional MRI scanner and ran it through a standard experimental protocol used in human emotion-recognition studies, showing the deceased fish photographs of people in social situations and asking it, exactly as a live human subject would be asked, to identify the emotion being displayed.[1] Without applying standard statistical corrections for the huge number of simultaneous comparisons an fMRI scan involves, the raw data showed apparent "brain activity" in the dead fish's brain cavity, activity that was in fact statistical noise, not a genuine neural signal, since the salmon was, as the researchers stated plainly, dead.[1]

The point[edit]

The study's actual purpose was to demonstrate, vividly, why fMRI researchers must apply multiple-comparisons statistical corrections: an fMRI scan tests tens of thousands of individual brain voxels simultaneously, and without correcting for that number of comparisons, a certain proportion will show "significant" results by pure chance alone, even in tissue that is unambiguously incapable of neural activity.[1] The paper was intended partly as advocacy within the neuroimaging field, at a time when a meaningful proportion of published fMRI studies were not applying the correction the salmon study demonstrated was necessary.[1]

Recognition[edit]

The study was awarded the 2012 Ig Nobel Prize in Neuroscience, an award given for research that "first makes people laugh, and then makes them think," which is widely regarded among the neuroimaging community as an entirely fitting description of this particular fish.[2]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Craig M. Bennett et al., "Neural Correlates of Interspecies Perspective Taking in the Post-Mortem Atlantic Salmon: An Argument For Multiple Comparisons Correction," poster presented at the Organization for Human Brain Mapping conference, 2009.
  2. ^ Improbable Research, "2012 Ig Nobel Prize Winners," Neuroscience category citation.

Rate this article

Two questions, two separate answers. An article can be useless and hilarious, or accurate and dull; the ratings are kept apart so editors can tell which problem they have. Anonymous ratings are counted per IP address.

Was this helpful?Did you actually learn the thing? No ratings yet
Was this funny?Did the joke land, and was it true? No ratings yet