George V
| Died | 20 January 1936 |
|---|---|
| Physician | Lord Dawson of Penn |
| What the notes say the timing was for | the morning papers, not the evening ones |
| Notes released | November 1986, from the Royal Archives |
| Royal comment in 1986 | none |
George V died on 20 January 1936. For fifty years the public account was a natural death. In November 1986 his physician's notes came out of the Royal Archives, and they were about a clock.[1][2]
The injections[edit]
The Los Angeles Times, on 28 November 1986, reported that historian Francis Watson, writing in History Today, said Lord Dawson of Penn had injected the dying king with morphine and cocaine. Watson said the 70-year-old king's doctor gave separate injections about 40 minutes before the death on 20 January 1936. Watson had published a biography of Dawson in 1950 and had not, the Times says, mentioned the lethal dose then.[1]
A biographer of the king called the actions "nothing short of murder." Sir Douglas Black, a former president of the Royal College of Physicians, called the reported action "evil." The Times notes that euthanasia was illegal in Britain. The Royal Family's comment, through press secretary Michael Shea, was that there was no comment, because the events were a long time ago.[1]
The edition[edit]
The sentence in the notes, printed by the Times, is: "The determination of the time of death of the King's body had another object in view, viz the importance of the death receiving its first announcement in the morning papers rather than the less appropriate field of the evening journals." Dawson wrote that he told his wife, on the telephone, to advise The Times to hold back publication.[1]
Gale's account, drawing on the Daily Telegraph of 27 November 1986, says Dawson consulted Queen Mary and the king's son Edward, who instructed him not to prolong the king's life unnecessarily, and that Dawson took that as leave to shorten it. The Gale piece says peace came within 15 minutes and that he was dead 25 minutes after that, before midnight, so The Times could run it in the morning edition. It quotes the same Dawson sentence about morning papers and evening journals.[2]
The historian who doubted it[edit]
Iverach McDonald, who wrote an official history of The Times, said he doubted the story. "From my knowledge of the Times I would be very much surprised if anything of the kind occurred," he said.[1]
The same report says George V had reigned 26 years and was succeeded by his eldest son as Edward VIII, who abdicated 11 months later. Edward was then the Duke of Windsor. His brother became George VI.[1]
Gale dates the notes' release to November 1986 and the Daily Telegraph's report to 27 November 1986. The Los Angeles Times story is 28 November. The two pages print the same Dawson sentence about morning papers and evening journals. Gale adds the clock: peace within 15 minutes, dead 25 minutes later, the whole business done before midnight.[2][1] The Times adds the people who objected in 1986, and the press secretary who would not.[1]
The king was dying on 20 January 1936. The argument that survived in the notes is which newspaper would print it first.
References[edit]
- ^ "Controversy Flares Over King's Mercy Killing", Los Angeles Times, from Times Wire Services, 28 November 1986. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1986-11-28-mn-15949-story.html
- ^ Sydney Fairman, "The Peculiar Death of King George V – As First Reported in the Times", Gale blog, 30 November 2018, updated 4 March 2019, quoting the physician's notes and the Daily Telegraph of 27 November 1986. https://blog.gale.com/the-peculiar-death-of-king-george-v-as-first-reported-in-the-times/