The Beatles
| Last concert | 30 January 1969, roof of 3 Savile Row, 42 minutes |
|---|---|
| Ed sullivan | 9 February 1964, 8 o'clock, Studio 50, audience of 700 |
| Seat requests that night | over 50,000 |
The Beatles were turned down, in the sentence Brian Epstein put in a book, by someone who did not like "groups of four guitarists." The short line that came later was denied by the man it was pinned on. On 30 January 1969 they played what Britannica calls their final concert together, on a roof, for 42 minutes. On 9 February 1964 a studio that held 700 people had more than 50,000 requests for seats.[1][2][3]
The sentence in the 1964 book[edit]
Quote Investigator checked Brian Epstein's A Cellarful of Noise (1964) against scans. The sentence QI could verify, posted 27 April 2013 and updated through 18 February 2025, is: "Not to mince words, Mr. Epstein, we don't like your boys' sound. Groups of four guitarists are on the way out." Epstein's reply in the same passage: "You must be out of your mind. These boys are going to explode. I am completely confident that one day they will be bigger than Elvis Presley." QI dates the Decca audition to New Year's Day 1962, from Epstein's account, and says the wording is Epstein's memory.[1]
That is the earliest form QI could verify. The page says the wording is Epstein's memory.[1]
The man who was not in the room[edit]
The Independent, Brian Viner, 11 February 2012, takes the shorter line "Guitar groups are on their way out, Mr Epstein." Those words were quoted by Epstein in the 1964 autobiography. Dick Rowe went to his grave in 1986 denying it. Rowe was not present at the audition. Mike Smith chose to offer a recording contract to the Tremeloes, not least because they came from Dagenham. The Beatles performed 15 songs.[4]
Mark Lewisohn, as reported in that piece, found a duller offer. Rowe had offered to press their records, at their expense, not Decca's. Epstein rejected that in a letter dated Saturday, 10 February 1962. George Martin told Lewisohn that, on the basis of those demos, he would have turned them down too.[4]
A direct interview with Rowe was not opened. The denial is The Independent's report.[4]
No transcript of the audition itself was among the pages opened here. What those pages have is Epstein's 1964 memory, the denial as The Independent reports it, and the letter of 10 February 1962.
How the wording got shorter[edit]
Quote Investigator tracks the shrink. Hunter Davies, The Beatles: The Authorized Biography (1968), has Epstein saying "Groups of guitars were on the way out." The tidy line, "We don't like their sound. Groups of guitars are on the way out," attributed to Decca Recording Company, shows up in Stephen Pile's The Book of Heroic Failures (1979).[1]
The 1964 wording is the one QI ties to the book. The 1968 wording is shorter. The 1979 wording is the one QI finds attributed to Decca Recording Company.[1]
The roof[edit]
Britannica's "Today in History" page for 30 January says that in the early afternoon of 30 January 1969, on the rooftop of Apple Corps headquarters, the Beatles played what would turn out to be their final concert together. The set was 42 minutes, cut short by police intervention. The songs named are "One After 909," "Dig a Pony," and "I've Got a Feeling," plus several renditions of "Get Back" and "Don't Let Me Down," and an improvised "God Save the Queen." The address is 3 Savile Row. Billy Preston joined the Fab Four. Arrests were threatened. No charges were brought. The Let It Be sessions left 210 hours of video and audio.[2]
A line often hung on the end of that set, about hoping they had passed the audition, was not on the Britannica page or the other pages opened here. It is left out.[2]
Studio 50[edit]
The Beatles' own site, in a news item dated 9 February 2016, says the Ed Sullivan broadcast was watched by an estimated 73 million viewers in over 23 million households, a record for American television at the time.[5] That 73 million is the site's "estimated" figure. A police or Nielsen document for it was not opened. A line on the Beatles site about no reported crimes is explicitly hearsay there, and it is not used here as a statistic.[5]
The Ed Sullivan Show's artist page gives the rating as a record-setting 45.3, and 23,240,000 American homes, a 60 share. CBS's TV Studio 50 could only accommodate an audience of 700. There were over 50,000 requests for seats. The show was at 8 o'clock on 9 February 1964. When the camera reached John Lennon, the caption under his name also read "SORRY GIRLS, HE'S MARRIED." Asked "How do you find America?", Ringo Starr said: "Turn left at Greenland." The booking was a handshake: on Monday, 11 November 1963, Epstein met Sullivan at the Delmonico Hotel.[3]
The set that night, on the same page: "All My Loving," "Till There Was You," "She Loves You," and later "I Saw Her Standing There" and "I Want to Hold Your Hand."[3]
The February 24, 1964 issue of Newsweek, quoted on that page: "Visually, they are a nightmare: tight, dandified, Edwardian/Beatnik suits and great pudding bowls of hair." The quoted review ended with "the odds are they will fade away, as most adults confidently predict."[3]
The Beatles site says over 23 million households. The Sullivan site says 23,240,000 homes. Both figures are on the pages. They are not collapsed here into one Nielsen number, because no Nielsen document was opened.[5][3]
More than 50,000 people asked for a seat. The room held 700. The caption under John Lennon said he was married.
References[edit]
- ^ Quote Investigator, "Guitar Groups Are on the Way Out, Mr. Epstein," posted 27 April 2013, updated through 18 February 2025. https://quoteinvestigator.com/2013/04/27/guitars-out/
- ^ Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Today in History," 30 January, on the Beatles' final concert. https://www.britannica.com/today-in-history/January-30-The-Beatles-Final-Concert
- ^ The Ed Sullivan Show, artist page for the Beatles. https://www.edsullivan.com/artists/the-beatles/
- ^ Brian Viner, "The man who rejected the Beatles," The Independent, 11 February 2012. https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/news/the-man-who-rejected-the-beatles-6782008.html
- ^ The Beatles, "9th February 1964: The Beatles make their Ed Sullivan Show debut," 9 February 2016. https://www.thebeatles.com/9th-february-1964-beatles-make-their-ed-sullivan-show-debut