WitipediaIt's funny because it's true.
Create account Log in

Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company

From Witipedia, the funny encyclopedia
Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company
CourtCourt of Appeal of England and Wales
Citation[1893] 1 QB 256
JudgesLindley, Bowen and A. L. Smith LJJ
Advertisement£100 if you use the smoke ball and still catch influenza
Deposited to show sincerity£1,000, Alliance Bank, Regent Street
ResultMrs Carlill was paid

Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company [1893] 1 QB 256 is a decision of the English Court of Appeal about an advertisement. The Carbolic Smoke Ball Company offered £100 to anyone who used its product as directed and then caught influenza. It added that £1,000 had been deposited with the Alliance Bank, Regent Street, "showing our sincerity in the matter". Louisa Carlill used the ball, caught influenza, and sued for the £100. She won.[1]

The product[edit]

The smoke ball was a rubber ball with a nozzle, filled so that the user could inhale the vapour of carbolic acid. The directions were three times a day for two weeks. Mrs Carlill bought one, used it from 20 November 1891, and had influenza on 17 January 1892. Her husband, a solicitor, wrote to the company. The company did not pay.[2]

Why it was a contract[edit]

The company said the advertisement was a puff, too vague to be a promise, and that sniffing a smoke ball in the privacy of one's own home could not be an acceptance of an offer, because nobody had been told. The Court of Appeal disagreed on each point.[1]

Lindley LJ read the bank deposit as the end of the puff argument. A statement that £1,000 was sitting at the Alliance Bank to show sincerity had, he said, no other purpose than to stop anyone thinking the offer was an empty boast. He finished with the consequence: the defendants would have to perform their promise, "and, if they have been so unwary as to expose themselves to a great many actions, so much the worse for them."[2]

Bowen LJ dealt with the question of consideration, which is the law's word for whether each side has given something. Using the ball counted. A person who "applies thrice daily, for such time as may seem to him tolerable, the carbolic smoke ball to his nostrils for a whole fortnight" had, at the company's request, put up with quite enough.[2]

The company had deposited the money in order to be believed. It was believed, and then it was held to what it had said.

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company [1893] 1 QB 256 (Court of Appeal).
  2. ^ Australian Contract Law, case note on Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company [1893] 1 QB 256, setting out the advertisement and the judgments.

Rate this article

Two questions, two separate answers. An article can be useless and hilarious, or accurate and dull; the ratings are kept apart so editors can tell which problem they have. Anonymous ratings are counted per IP address.

Was this helpful?Did you actually learn the thing? No ratings yet
Was this funny?Did the joke land, and was it true? No ratings yet