Jaffa Cakes
| Maker | McVitie's, part of United Biscuits |
|---|---|
| Legal question | cake or biscuit |
| Why it mattered | chocolate cakes are zero-rated for VAT; chocolate biscuits are not |
| Decided | VAT tribunal, 1991, LON/91/0160 |
| Held | cake |
Jaffa Cakes are a small sponge, orange jelly and chocolate snack sold by McVitie's. For most of their history the interesting question about them was how many were in the packet. In 1991 the question was whether they were cakes, because a cake covered in chocolate is zero-rated for value added tax in the United Kingdom, and a biscuit covered in chocolate is not.[1]
The argument[edit]
Customs and Excise had treated Jaffa Cakes as cakes, and therefore as zero-rated, since VAT began. It had misgivings. After a review it changed its mind and classed them as biscuits partly covered in chocolate, which are standard-rated. United Biscuits, which owns McVitie's, appealed to a VAT tribunal.[1]
The tribunal went through the differences one at a time. The name was a minor consideration. The sponge was made from egg, flour and sugar, aerated on cooking, the same mixture as a traditional sponge cake, and it was a batter rather than a biscuit dough. The texture was soft and friable, where a biscuit is crisp and snaps. The size pointed the other way: a Jaffa Cake is about the size of a biscuit. So did the packaging, which looks like a biscuit packet, and the marketing, which puts them on the shelf with the biscuits. They are eaten with the fingers, in a few mouthfuls, which is not how anyone eats a slice of cake.[1]
The stale test[edit]
One factor was what happens when the product is left alone. A cake goes hard as it goes stale. A biscuit goes soft. A Jaffa Cake goes hard.[1]
Taken together, the tribunal found characteristics of both, and enough of the characteristics of cakes to hold that Jaffa Cakes were cakes. They stayed zero-rated.[1] An earlier tribunal, about a chocolate-based shortcake called Chocolate Dundees, had gone the other way and classed that product as a biscuit. The difference was not philosophical. It was that the tribunal, looking at the Dundee, could not see any factor that made it a cake.[1]
The tax on a chocolate-covered snack in Britain depends, in part, on whether it stiffens with age.
See also[edit]
References[edit]
- ^ HM Revenue and Customs, VAT Food manual, VFOOD6260, "The borderline between cakes and biscuits", citing United Biscuits (LON/91/0160).