Pringles
| Maker | Procter & Gamble |
|---|---|
| Legal question | are Regular Pringles similar to potato crisps, and made from the potato |
| Why it mattered | if yes, standard-rate VAT; if no, zero-rate |
| Court | Court of Appeal of England and Wales |
| Citation | [2009] EWCA Civ 407 |
| Potato flour | over 40 per cent of Regular Pringles, the largest single ingredient |
| Held | yes, and yes |
Pringles are a stacked savoury snack made by Procter & Gamble. In Britain, whether they were potato crisps was worth, on the Revenue's figures in court, about £100 million in tax for the years already gone and about £20 million a year afterwards. Potato crisps are standard-rated for VAT. Most food is not. The statute catches crisps, sticks, puffs, and "similar products made from the potato, or from potato flour, or from potato starch".[1]
Regular Pringles are about 40 per cent potato flour. The rest is corn flour, wheat starch, rice flour, fat and seasoning. Procter & Gamble said that was not "made from the potato". The Court of Appeal said it was.
The question[edit]
Lord Justice Jacob opened the judgment by stating the question and the money, and then warned that this was not a problem that called for "over-elaborate, almost mind-numbing legal analysis". The tribunal had already found the facts: what was in the product, how it was made, what it looked like, what it tasted like, and where it was sold. An appeal court, he said, should be slow to redo a classification of that kind.[1][2]
The test in the statute is double. The product has to be similar to a potato crisp, and it has to be made from potato, potato flour or potato starch. The company argued that "made from" meant wholly, or nearly wholly. Jacob observed that even a potato crisp is not 100 per cent potato, so Parliament was unlikely to have required a copy of a crisp to be purer than the crisp. The tribunal had found the potato flour was over 40 per cent, the largest ingredient by about nine points, and nearly three times the other flours put together. That was enough to be "made from" it. Being made from other things as well did not cancel the potato.[3]
The High Court had gone the other way. The Court of Appeal restored the tribunal. Regular Pringles were similar enough, and potato enough, and standard-rated.[1]
A stack of identical curved snacks was held to be a potato crisp for tax, by a court that had begun by asking everyone not to overthink it.